The Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof – BGH) on 5 March 2015 issued a decision (case no. IX ZR 133/14, available here) that is of immense relevance for all creditors and debtors that face the need of a subordination agreement (Rangrücktrittvereinbarung) under German law.
The German Government proposes amendments to the German insolvency Act (‘InsO’), which will limit the insolvency administrator’s rescission rights, especially his claims under s. 133 para 1 InsO.
Current Law
Overview
In November 2015, the German legislator passed the Resolution Mechanism Act (Abwicklungsmechanismusgesetz, AbwMechG). The law introduces, among other things, Section 46f (5) et seqq. of the German Banking Act (Kreditwesengesetz, KWG), which requires that claims under certain unsecured debt instruments be subordinated to general senior unsecured obligations in an insolvency proceeding involving a German bank.
On March 3 2015 the Hamburg Local Court (67a IN 400/14) expressly contradicted the Bremen Regional Court's August 14 2011 decision (2 T 435/11) regarding whether vessels are protected from arrest during preliminary insolvency proceedings (for further details please see "Are vessels protected from arrest du
In a judgment dated 26 / 03 / 2015, ref. no. IX ZR 302 / 13, the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) held that a provisional insolvency administrator is personally liable for monies paid into the escrow account in the event of claims of unjust enrichment being made due to the payments having no proper basis in law.
The ruling related to the following situation:
Mit Urteil vom 26. März 2015, AZ IX ZR 302 / 13, entschied der BGH, dass ein vorläufiger Insolvenzver- walter für Zahlungen auf das Voll- rechtstreuhandkonto persönlich haf- tet, wenn Bereicherungsansprüche wegen rechtsgrundloser Zahlungen geltend gemacht werden.
Dieser Entscheidung lag folgender Sachverhalt zu Grunde:
Stillhalten oder Einfordern?
In a previous update on the German law perspective regarding bunker supplies, some significant problems associated with bunker supplies under German law were highlighted (for further details please see "Bunker supplies – maritime lien and risk of vessel arrest").
Key point
The restructuring of the AVK Group shows what chances the “Law for Further Facilitating the Restructuring of Companies” provides regarding the restructuring of group entities in the group structure and incorporating them back into the group.
Background
Report contents: