Two recent decisions of the Tribunals of Ferrara (8 April 2014) and Palermo (9 June 2014) address some of the majorissues involved in group restructurings under Italian insolvency laws: conditions and features of a single “concordatopreventivo” procedure for all the companies of the same group

The Case

In a case where NCTM assisted the debtor, the Court of Appeals of Turin, with a decision of 17 April 2014, confirmed the most recent case law of the Court of Cassation limiting the power of the Tribunal to refuse confirmation to cases where, beyond doubt, the concordato is not economically feasible.

The case

The Tribunal of Naples, with a decision of 5 July 2013 in an interim proceeding, ruled that the Commissioner and the Judicial Liquidator can sue former directors for damages only if the claim (i) was included in the concordato proposal, or (ii) has grounds in tort, for facts entailing bankruptcy crimes.

The Case

In a recent decision, the Tribunal of Monza (23 October 2014) ruled that super-priority status can be denied if it is established that (i) professional duties were not properly performed or (ii) the concordato proved to be useless or detrimental for the creditors.

The Case

Wanneer de rechtbank de procedure van gerechtelijke reorganisatie met het oog op de overdracht onder gerechtelijk gezag voor een onderneming in moeilijkheden voor geopend verklaart, verleent zij hierbij een bepaalde periode van opschorting waarbinnen de overdracht gerealiseerd dient te worden. 

Pour rappel, en cas d’approbation d’un plan de réorganisation judiciaire par la majorité des créanciers, il appartient au Tribunal de commerce d’homologuer le plan approuvé pour autant qu’il ne soit pas contraire à l’ordre public. 

Selon l’article 49, § 1 de la loi du 31 janvier 2009 relative à la continuité des entreprises, le plan de réorganisation peut prévoir le règlement différencié de certaines catégories de créances, notamment en fonction de leur ampleur ou de leur nature.

La Cour d’appel de Mons a encore récemment rappelé la responsabilité attachée à la fonction de liquidateur d’une société commerciale.

De Europese Commissie heeft op 15 mei 2014 de definitieve versie van de Europese verordening betreffende het beslag op bankrekeningen goedgekeurd. Deze verordening is het resultaat van jarenlange besprekingen en kadert in het plan tot versoepeling van de invorderingsprocedures tussen Europese lidstaten.

In the Schmid case the European Court of Justice ruled on the issue of jurisdiction of the Courts of a Member State ofthe EU where an insolvency procedure was commenced, whose receiver started a claw-back action against a defendantdomiciled in a non-Member State

The Case

The Tribunal of Milan with a decision of 12 June 2014 took a stand which is in sharp contrast with mainstreamcase-law, with respect to clauses – widely used as common practice in distressed assets deals as part of“concordato preventivo” restructurings based on an interim lease of business period while the insolvencyproceeding is pending – allowing the lessee to apply rental fee payments to the final purchase price of the business,once the “concordato” is confirmed and the sale can take place